Solved - MJW #1058 - Binnie MG Holden Special 1953

Started by woodinsight, December 12, 2012, 05:12:31 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Wendax

This car was built by Holt Binnie in 1953.

woodinsight

That's it - well found Wendax. Yet another point for you.

Holt Binnie's business was the recycling and restoration of Holden crankshafts.
He later raced a standard MG TF fitted with a special Holden engine and later acquired the Gladiator, a Holden-engined sports racer fitted with a Buchanan body.

Craig Gillingham

#27
I can guarantee it's not a Holden engine. I'd say your source is incorrect.

woodinsight

Quote from: Craig Gillingham on January 08, 2013, 07:34:41 PM
I can guarantee it's not a Holden engine. I'd say your source is incorrect.
Interesting Craig - I've been trying to find the source I obtained the puzzle photo from without success.

Are you saying the engine is an MG (modified TD?)
If so I will alter the heading and allocate additional points where they are due.....

Craig Gillingham

It looks like an MG engine to me or at least something BMC related, but I'm unsure, I would get a second opinion. I understand you're probably not familiar with Holden engines, but I can assure you, in this case it isn't a Holden engine. The Holden Grey motors (they were painted grey) went from 1948-63, and they used the same basic engine configuration for the 6 cylinders up to the mid 80's.

woodinsight

Quote from: Craig Gillingham on January 09, 2013, 03:39:35 AM
It looks like an MG engine to me or at least something BMC related, but I'm unsure, I would get a second opinion. I understand you're probably not familiar with Holden engines, but I can assure you, in this case it isn't a Holden engine. The Holden Grey motors (they were painted grey) went from 1948-63, and they used the same basic engine configuration for the 6 cylinders up to the mid 80's.
Thanks Craig, that looks convincing to me.

Anyone with a second opinion?

Paul Jaray

The puzzle car should be Holt Binnie's alloy bodied MG TD.
The MG-Holden Special was this: an MG TF with an Holden Grey six.