A design that never materialized.
For one point, please respond and identify the designer and the car it should have been.
up
Italian designer?
No
Lovely little thing. Is there a Simca 1000 underneath? ???
No Simca 1000 involved
Italian ?
No
German?
Yes
NSU ?
No
Glas ?
No
Audi ?
No
Borgward ?
No
VW?
No
DKW
No
Was the body designed in Italy?
No
Opel?
If not, is the manufacturer still in existence today?
Not Opel
Quote from: AlexFrance on July 05, 2015, 06:01:03 PM
Opel?
If not, is the manufacturer still in existence today?
Quote from: richard cuyler on July 06, 2015, 05:47:56 AM
If not, is the manufacturer still in existence today?
Yes
(Sometimes I don't like to answer two questions at a time. ;) )
BMW?
Yes, that was the easy bit. Now I need the designer.
Was the designer from the USA?
Albrecht Goetz ?
Twice no
Was it a proposal designed outside of BMW?
It seems to be rear-engined, so is it perhaps a Wilhelm Hofmeister design proposal for an updated BMW 700? To me, though, it looks very Italian, something Vignale may have been proud to present. ??? ???
Quote from: AlexFrance on July 06, 2015, 05:51:30 PM
Was it a proposal designed outside of BMW?
Yes
Quote from: richard cuyler on July 06, 2015, 07:15:48 PM
It seems to be rear-engined, so is it perhaps a Wilhelm Hofmeister design proposal for an updated BMW 700? To me, though, it looks very Italian, something Vignale may have been proud to present. ??? ???
You are right about the base car, but it was not done by Wilhelm Hofmeister.
Quote from: Wendax on July 07, 2015, 02:48:12 AM
Quote from: richard cuyler on July 06, 2015, 07:15:48 PM
It seems to be rear-engined, so is it perhaps a Wilhelm Hofmeister design proposal for an updated BMW 700? To me, though, it looks very Italian, something Vignale may have been proud to present. ??? ???
You are right about the base car, but it was not done by Wilhelm Hofmeister.
Just to make things perfectly clear, do you confirm that the base car is a BMW 700?
Yes
Was it designed by a German individual/studio?
Yes, we had designs by him at AP before.
Was it a proposal for a regular BMW 700 or a specific version, for instance a 700 RS or a 700 LS Luxus Cabriolet?
I have to correct myself. Judging by the year this drawing was made, it is not based on a 700, but on another rear-engined BMW.
Based on my -highly- limited knowledge of BMW cars, I can think only of one another rear-engined one: the BMW 600.
But it doesn't look like that's the base of that car, or is it?
Unless it's a model that was not badged under the BMW name?
I think that BMW 600 is right. Remember that it is just a drawing that never materialized. :)
Quote from: Wendax on July 07, 2015, 01:50:24 PM
I think that BMW 600 is right. Remember that it is just a drawing that never materialized. :)
Ok! :)
Now, let's try to find the designer of that car. What about Baur?
Not Baur
Karmann?
Not Karmann, and not by a coachbuilder at all.
So this is the name of an individual we are looking for?
Yes
A calculated guess: Renzo Rivolta?
No
This could go on for a while...Luigi Colani?
No
Is that person known for designing cars?
Not only, but: yes.
oops, sorry missed the input that it was a BMW.
Last guess, even though it looks nothing like one of his designs: Raymond Loewy?
Quote from: richard cuyler on July 24, 2015, 12:42:34 PM
Last guess, even though it looks nothing like one of his designs: Raymond Loewy?
Bump...... :)
Quote from: richard cuyler on July 27, 2015, 08:35:03 AM
Quote from: richard cuyler on July 24, 2015, 12:42:34 PM
Last guess, even though it looks nothing like one of his designs: Raymond Loewy?
Bump...... :)
Wendax is on holiday for a couple of weeks, I believe without his computer!
What a sound decision to leave those sorts of things at home. ;D 8)
For when he gets home: Claus Luthe?
Michelotti BMW proposal?
Neither Loewy, Luthe, nor Michelotti
up again
Philippe Charbonneaux ?
No
Are we looking for a German designer ?
Yes
Michael Conrad ?
No
Has this designer ever worked inside the design studio of a German car make ?
Peter Szymanowski?
Quote from: oko94 on August 09, 2015, 06:19:45 AM
Has this designer ever worked inside the design studio of a German car make ?
Yes
Quote from: pnegyesi on August 09, 2015, 06:38:28 AM
Peter Szymanowski?
No
Did he work at BMW ?
Yes
Alex von Falkenhausen ?
No
Manfred Rennen ?
No
Georg Bertram ?
No
Was this designer still alive in 1980 ?
Yes
Colani?
No
Franz Trüby?
No
Reinhard von Koenig-Fachsenfeld ?
No
Rudolf Schleicher ?
No
Did this designer work for another German car make before/after BMW ?
Yes
Did he work for Ford ?
Yes
Boyke Boyer ?
No
Wilhelm Hofmeister
Uwe Bahnsen ?
Twice no
Was this designer born before 1940 ?
Yes
Klaus Kapitza ?
No
Erich Palm ?
No
Albrecht von Goertz?
No
Is this designer still alive ?
Yes
Was this designer born in the 1930s ?
Yes
Between 1930 and 1935 ?
Yes
1932 ?
No
1933 ?
No
1931 ?
No
I'm not very lucky with this puzzle !
1934 ?
No ;D
Dammit ! 1935 ?
Yes, I hope it will help you.
Hans A. Muth?
Tatatataaaah! It is indeed a Hans A. Muth design. One more point for you.